HIIT Advice From Cross-Fit “Legend” Carl Paoli (HIIT Challenge, Week 9)

As part of our HIIT Challenge, I caught up recently with Carl Paoli to discuss his perspectives on HIIT and advice for OlderBeasts on how to incorporate it into our fitness. Carl’s a former elite-level gymnast, a well-known leader in the CrossFit world, a bestselling author, a corporate mindset coach, and an entrepreneur. Above all, he’s a longtime student of physical movement and physical education – and so it’s great to have his perspective! (You can learn more about Carl here).

OlderBeast: You’ve been deeply involved in CrossFit for a long time. With that perspective, was CrossFit essentially “HIIT before everyone started talking about HIIT”?

by

As part of our HIIT Challenge, I caught up recently with Carl Paoli to discuss his perspectives on HIIT and advice for OlderBeasts on how to incorporate it into our fitness. Carl’s a former elite-level gymnast, a well-known leader in the CrossFit world, a bestselling author, a corporate mindset coach, and an entrepreneur. Above all, he’s a longtime student of physical movement and physical education – and so it’s great to have his perspective! (You can learn more about Carl here).

OlderBeast: You’ve been deeply involved in CrossFit for a long time. With that perspective, was CrossFit essentially “HIIT before everyone started talking about HIIT”?

Carl: Starting way back in the 90s, CrossFit highlighted the notion of constantly varied movements at high intensity. But the concept of high-intensity training goes back a lot farther than that. Personally, I learned high-intensity principles as a kid starting gymnastics training in 1988. And if you study history, you find high-intensity concepts dating all the way to the ancient Olympians.

So while HIIT may seem hot and new in a commercial sense, the idea of working at the end ranges of your metabolic capacity, to elicit great improvements in your base fitness, goes back thousands of years.

CrossFit was pioneering in that it brought HIIT principles into a branded philosophy. It brought HIIT from its heritage in elite athletic training into practicing such movements for everyday fitness.

Some boot camps and HIIT-focused boutiques position themselves as more-evolved versions of CrossFit – less risky and more beneficial for most people. What’s your perspective here?

First of all, let me clarify that I’m not directly associated with CrossFit as a business anymore. But I do think the average “Physical IQ” (or “PQ”) of most CrossFit affiliates’ instruction is higher than the average of these more-recent branded concepts.

This isn’t ideological or any kind of us-versus-them feeling. And it’s not meant as offense to the great teachers I know are out there. It’s just that, after all this time, CrossFit is a mature market where the cream has risen to the top in any given local market. Successful CrossFit affiliates that have been around a long time have a high level of knowledge related to quality movement practices. They wouldn’t still be in business otherwise.

By contrast, newer HIIT-focused concepts are in a rapid-growth market. New companies and concepts see a low barrier to entry. And so we see many new entrants. On average, and I think it’s logical, the “quality control” and experience level is less.

Seeking the best-quality instruction seems like advice that’s impossible to argue with. But convenience and concept-type sway people, too. Can you give an example of how higher-quality instruction really matters for HIIT?

Metabolic conditioning is easy to achieve. Just have people do an action at some minimum blend of difficulty and pace, and you’ll push them to the end of their metabolic range. That is, into an unsustainable heart-rate zone that will soon require a rest interval.

But designing movement routines that are most transferable to everyday life, and which safely contribute to mobility as well as strength and conditioning, is not so easy. For example, basics like squats or medicine balls throws have so many ways you can “do” them. And many ways you can do them incompletely, by the way. In many cases, some of the opportunity to improve fitness and overall quality-of-life is being left on the table.

One thing I notice about CrossFit people is they’re not just attending scheduled workouts. They’re frequently engaged in thinking about techniques, they’re watching videos online and talking to people. They’re students of all this in the larger sense.

I’m not necessarily plugging CrossFit here. But whatever flavor of HIIT you choose, look for qualifications and experience of instructors. And be a student of your fitness beyond the time you spend in fitness classes!

Whether via CrossFit, some other group-fitness concept or on our own — how often should 45+ guys be doing HIIT training?

Every day! But before you react to that, let me explain. You should have the experience of breathing heavily due to exertion, even if for just two minutes, every day. And high-intensity exertion doesn’t necessarily mean “fast” or “high-impact,” either. You can do slow, controlled things – like carrying a heavy weight – that will get you to that metabolic threshold.

With all the recent attention on HIIT, I think people understand the benefits of challenging your body to transform oxygen and nutrients into energy (to metabolize) at the limits of your capabilities. But people also worry about allowing sufficient recovery time, avoiding injury, and not over-stressing their bodily systems, I know.

I see resolving this tension as a matter of dosage. Yeah, for most people doing hard metabolic resistance training for an hour a day, many days per week, might be too much HIIT. But you should incorporate what Tim Ferris calls a “minimum effective dose” of HIIT into your everyday workouts. And, try to find that intensity from a variety of movement types.

Training and movement are medicine. We all need to be students of our own bodies and figure out the right prescription for ourselves. Whatever that is for you, though, should likely include at least small doses of HIIT on a frequent basis.

And don’t let the high-profile fitness brands and methods dictate to you exactly what this should be. Learn it for (and about) yourself!

You and other experts are talking about “mobility” a lot these days. I confess to an imperfect understanding of what this really means. Is it a more-sophisticated way to say “flexibility”?

Flexibility is a narrower concept. It’s about the body’s ability to be molded or shaped into certain forms. Mobility is about that and your ability to actually move into those forms and use them in athletics and daily life.

For example, under anesthesia, most people’s toe can be brought to their nose without any harm. They’re “flexible” enough to allow that. But when awake, they can’t adopt this shape. Their nervous system (and maybe mindset) resists. Mobility is about changing behaviors so over time we become more able to move our bodies in ways that promote fitness and maintain health. And which simply feel good, and free.

Think about this. In a yoga class, if you become more able to do a certain pose within the span of an individual class, you didn’t become more flexible in that hour. But you learned how to perform a movement, came to feel comfortable and safe doing it, and helped your nervous system to let you do it. That’s mobility.

And rather than thinking of “mobility” as a separate discipline you focus on in dedicated sessions, every workout should include mobility. Think about carefully exaggerating your movements just a little to go to a place where you find resistance, then spending some time to get comfortable there.

This could be reaching forward that extra half inch when you’re swimming, swinging that kettlebell just a bit farther back between your legs, getting your nose just a little closer to your knees in that forward fold. There are opportunities in everything we do.

Thinking of swimming and kettlebells brings my mind back to the subject of heart rate. And technology to measure it. How do you see fitness tech playing into a healthy HIIT habit?

Well, we live in a technology age. Wearables and smartphones can provide a good snapshot of what we’re doing heart-rate-wise, of course. There’s also movement toward being able to do more-advanced things, like measure sweat for a variety of purposes.

But all this data is not a substitute for being aware of and mindful about how we feel. Our bodies are way more complex than just heart rate. True performance can only be measured by how you’re feeling. That’s why my view on technology is “use it, but don’t succumb to it.”

And on a different dimension, I think people sometimes focus too much on tech-enabled performance data as a reflection of themselves and their worth. We’re at risk of putting all our emotional baggage into these numbers.

I like to try to remember that life doesn’t need to measured to be experienced.

###

You may also like

article-image
Challenges , Flexibility & Alternative Fitness

Four Online Yoga Sources for Busy (or Reluctant) Guys — Fall 2017 Yoga Challenge, Week 4

Fall 2017 Yoga Challenge, Week 4. If you need to catch up, no big deal (this is a self-paced challenge during Oct-Dec this year, and you don’t need 12-13 weeks to meet its basic goals). Click on “Yoga for Men” in the Challenges box to the left, to see Week 1 and other posts.

As a reminder, challenge goals are: (1) Do at least six yoga practices during October-December 2017; (2) Have those practices span at least two sources of instruction (yoga studio instructor or online class), including at least one in-person studio experience; (3) Achieve at least three weeks in a row where you get a yoga practice into your routine, during the span of this challenge; and (4) Decide by New Year’s if-and-how you will keep yoga as part of your fitness and wellness routine.

To seek these goals — and for life-with-yoga after the challenge, if you go that way — online yoga classes are a great resource. You can use them when you don’t have time to get to a studio, are traveling, or for any number of other reasons. Including this honest one: you’re just not “up for” doing yoga in public yet. I get that. I felt the same way. But after doing a bunch of online yoga practices, I knew enough about what an in-person class would entail — and could do “enough” of the stuff” — that I was ready to brave the studio.

So here are four recommended online yoga class offerings. Each has a bit of a different style. They all offer free or sub-$1 trial periods so you can experiment with two or more of them if you want.

article-image
Challenges , Strength

OlderBeast 90-Day Push-Up Challenge: Why & How

For 40+ guys intent on maximizing the second half of their lives, willingness to be a little New-Age-y helps. It opens your mind to things like eating more vegetables, doing yoga, and prioritizing “wellness.”

At the same time, for physical fitness, there are Old School things we should stick (or return) to. Like push-ups, man.

They build upper body (and core) strength we strive to maintain or restore, in a time-efficient way. And you can do them anytime, anywhere. That’s why push-ups should be an OlderBeast staple.

So, here’s a CHALLENGE to meaningfully increase your max push-ups # in the next 90 days.

article-image
Challenges

Introducing OlderBeast 2.0 with Seasonal Challenges

If you’re reading this…well, first of all, THANKS man. I truly value and feel honored by your engagement in OlderBeast.

If you’re reading this…you’re at the new, improved “OlderBeast 2.0.” Here’s an overview of new features and how to use them.

But first, one key thing has not changed. OlderBeast’s mission is to help 45+ guys double down on body-and-soul health, to maximize the 2nd half of life. Fitness, nutrition, wellness – and having these things contribute not only to our physical health but also to Joy and Meaning – that’s what this is all about.

With these guiding goals, “OB2” can be more customized for how you want to use it. It hopes to be more engaging, to invite and challenge (and help with) your “doing” vs. just “reading.” And to create (cliché alert, I know) community, so OlderBeast is more than a one-way thing.

article-image
Challenges

Fall 2017 HIIT Challenge: Week 3 (Sample HIIT Workouts)

Fall 2017 HIIT Challenge, Week 3! If you need to catch up, no big deal (this is a self-paced challenge during Oct-Dec this year, and you don’t need 12-13 weeks to meet its basic goals). Just click the HIIT Challenge link in the box to the left, to access the Week 1 intro to all this.

For this and other OlderBeast seasonal challenges (yoga’s the other current one), “best of the web” content is part of the rotation. I’m always looking for useful stuff, sometimes at the theory/rationale level, and a lot of times at the concrete “what-to and how-to” levels.

In that spirit, here are three HIIT-focused sources I think you’ll find useful, especially for doing things on your own vs. an instructor-led workout in person or via video (all of these are great things to try).

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.