High-Intensity Intervals (HIIT) or Longer/Moderate Workouts? Why You Need Some of Each.

A lot of research shows great benefits can come from shorter workouts (~25-35 minutes total) with alternating periods of high intensity and recovery. So should we stop doing “traditional” runs, bike rides, swims and other cardio sessions, and just do high-intensity interval training (HITT)?

Based on my own experience, a review of what experts are saying, and some simple logic about “why we exercise,” I think the answer is to seek the best of both worlds here.

Incorporate some HIIT benefits into your routine, but do also retain some longer, moderate cardio workouts. Here’s why, and some tips for getting started.

by

A lot of research shows great benefits can come from shorter workouts (~25-35 minutes total) with alternating periods of high intensity and recovery. So should we stop doing “traditional” runs, bike rides, swims and other cardio sessions, and just do high-intensity interval training (HITT)?

Based on my own experience, a review of what experts are saying, and some simple logic about “why we exercise,” I think the answer is to seek the best of both worlds here.

Incorporate some HIIT benefits into your routine, man. But do also retain some longer, moderate cardio workouts. Here’s why, and some tips for getting started.

BENEFITS OF HIGH-INTENSITY INTERVAL WORKOUTS

The benefits of running for 30+ minutes, or doing the equivalent on a bike or in the pool, are pretty well understood. But since HIIT benefits are a more-recently-emerging science, let’s briefly review the logic of “why HITT.”

  • HITT offers a higher “fitness gained for time spent” ratio than longer, moderate workouts.
  • If intervals include strength moves, you get strength and cardio work at the same time. Great if you’re crunched for time, or want to add a “mini” strength session to a traditional cardio workout that can thus be shortened a little without sacrificing overall cardio time.
  • For weight loss, HITT burns similar calories in less workout time. It then has a metabolic “afterburn” effect that keeps burning calories for longer post-workout.

Use your time more-efficiently, mix cardio and strength, and burn more calories. These are some major benefits, brother. So if you’re not doing it already, try some HITT activities (see “take action” below for pointers).

IMPLICATIONS FOR LONGER, MODERATE-INTENSITY WORKOUTS

So should we all stop doing >30-minute, continuous-effort runs, long weekend bike rides, or modest-effort, “just get a sweat” cardio-machine sessions?

I don’t think so, for four reasons.

  1. Longer, moderate cardio workouts are a real mind-and-soul cleanse (especially outdoor ones). Tune out the world, go into a zone, and by the end feel mentally, not just physically, refreshed.
  2. A lot of us just *like* running and cycling. Reason #1 here is part of why, but they’re also the chance to take in nice scenery and exercise in a social way with others. And doing exercise you like is the best way to stay motivated.
  3. One thing longer, moderate cardio is definitely better for: getting in shape to do longer, moderate cardio things! So if running races and triathlons are motivational and fun for you, then you need to train for the events by doing the underlying activities.
  4. Finally, we all need days that are lower-key and lower-effort to counter-balance intense things. This is especially true for 40+ OlderBeasts. These lower-key days help keep fitness momentum while still allowing some recovery for muscles and our overall energy-delivery system. There’s also a certain mental and overall systemic stress that comes along with high-intensity physical work, and these lower-key days help us dissipate that.

TAKE ACTION

OK, so where does this leave us?

If you’re just starting off or re-starting a workout routine, I suggest you incorporate both HITT and longer/moderate workouts into it from the get-go.

For guys who are already runners, cyclists, and long/slow types of cardio machine users, I suggest you explore interval training, and fold it into your routine. Even if it requires reducing “pure” cardio in order to have time, dude. You’ll be glad you did.

Useful things to read about all this:

 

“Everyday, it’s a-gettin’ faster. Everyone said, “Go ahead and ask her.” (Buddy Holly & The Crickets, Everyday – click-to-listen)

 

If you think this would be useful to others, please help spread the word about OlderBeast by sharing this post with the social media buttons below. THANKS, MAN.

You may also like

article-image
Fitness Planning & Gear , Nutrition & Recipes

Weight Maintenance? Why You Need Some “Loss” Days to Balance Inevitable “Gain” Days.

Unless you live with otherworldly consistency, even “weight maintenance” will have small ups-and-downs. Some days, calories from food and drink exceed those you burn. For maintenance, then, you need other days when calories burned exceed those consumed.

Here’s an illustration of how inevitable—and how high-impact— “calorie surplus” days are. And then, suggestions for how to balance them with modest, measured “calorie deficit” responses.

article-image
Fitness Planning & Gear , Philosophy & Motivation

Fitness as We Age: Five Lessons From the “Ground Game” in Football

I love football analogies, man. I probably use them too much. I ought to invoke the images of a symphony or a wild-flowered meadow more often.

But some football analogies just make sense to me at a visceral level. Especially this one: pursuing long-term body-and-soul health (at 40, 50, 60 and beyond) is like committing to the run as a football strategy.

When a team declares “we WILL run the football,” they commit to guiding principles like: Having a more-patient approach to victory – not trying to “win quickly”…Depending less on flashy or gimmicky approaches – what you see is mainly what you get…and Reducing costly mistakes – fumbles are less common and less damaging than interceptions.

Let’s consider what lessons this holds for the pursuit of decades-long fitness. I see five of them.

article-image
Endurance , Philosophy & Motivation

Study Says Running’s the Biggest Life Extender. Give Credit to Runners’ “Architect” Fitness Approach.

This week, the NY Times cited a Cooper Institute study that found running is correlated with a higher increase in life span than any other exercise. (“An Hour of Running May Add 7 Hours to Your Life” – see link below).

The study’s authors acknowledge this is a “correlation” and not “causation” finding. Quick illustration of causation vs. correlation. A guy keeps finding when he sleeps with his clothes and shoes on, he wakes up with a headache. Did sleeping that way cause the headache? No, it was correlated with it (they frequently happen together), with the common root cause being tequila the night before.

My hunch is this finding is an important correlation between running and positive lifespan impact. It’s not the running itself causing incremental benefit vs. other exercise types. Other exercises or mixes thereof can provide the same physical and mind-body benefits. It’s that, critically, runners are likely to have an “Architect” view of their own fitness, and associated sustainable behavior patterns. These are the causative factors behind maximum exercise impact.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.