Small Trick to Help You Eat Better: Best Way to Stir “Natural” Peanut Butter

OlderBeast address vital topics like lifelong fitness, nutrition, happiness…and now, peanut butter.

For those of us who eat “natural” or “old fashioned” peanut butter, stirring together the peanut/oil separation when you first open a jar is a messy PAIN.

Here’s the solution I figured out – just recently, after a decade or so of dealing with this low-grade pain.


OlderBeast addresses vital topics like lifelong fitness, nutrition, happiness…and now, peanut butter.

Granted, this post might not be non-life-changing (unless you eat a lot of peanut butter and if so, hopefully it will be).  But for those of us who eat “natural” or “old fashioned” peanut butter, stirring together the peanut/oil separation when you first open a jar is a messy PAIN.

If you know this already, feel free to skip the next section and get to the solution! If not, please invest 60 seconds to read this in its entirety – you’re here anyway, man.

Natural Peanut Butter: Context

First off, peanut butter is a great contributor to a man’s nutrition program.  Walnuts, almonds and pistachios each have strong benefits, too, so this isn’t recommending it over them.  But peanut butter is convenient, affordable, high-protein, filling…and tasty. Yes, it’s pretty caloric, so watch quantity if you’re carefully managing weight.

And you should use natural peanut butter. Why? Natural peanut butter has one ingredient (peanuts)…or two if you get the salted kind like I do (it’s just a little bit of salt).

“Normal” peanut butter has added sugar, and hydrogenated oils that prevent oil separation in the jar.  Those are two bad ingredients for an OlderBeast seeking health.

So what’s the downside of natural?

When you first open a jar, there’s layer of pure peanut oil floating on top of the peanut butter below.  The directions say “stir, then refrigerate” – doesn’t sound like a big deal.

But the peanut butter layer is pretty firm (without its natural oil blended in), and the physical stirring effort often causes the oil layer to splash over the top of the jar, down the jar’s sides, onto your hands and the kitchen counter. That’s the “pain” part (and hence the paper towel you’ll notice in the image above).

It might not sound like much, but everyone I know who uses natural peanut butter hates this.

The Solution

Here’s the solution I figured out – just recently, after a decade or so of dealing with the low-grade pain described above.

Firstly, do not refrigerate the jar before opening – keep it in the cabinet.

1. When you first open the jar, pour most of the “floating” oil layer into a coffee cup or small bowl, and keep it handy

2. Stir up the remaining peanut butter, the smaller amount of oil and (for “crunchy” variations – my favorite) the small bits of peanuts

3. From the mixed stuff in the jar, use your first serving of peanut butter onto a sandwich, with an apple, or see my favorite 30-second peanut butter lunch concoction (below)

4. Then, once you’ve reduced the quantity in the jar via this first serving, pour the rest of the oil back into the jar and stir everything up…with more vertical “safety space” above the level of the jar’s contents

Now refrigerate and use the rest of the jar, being happy that you didn’t spill oil all over the place as that jar’s inaugural act!

Simplest Awesome Peanut Butter Recipe: “PBJ &B” Burrito

My family thinks I’m goofy for doing this (they have other reasons, too).  But I love it: the peanut butter, jelly, and banana burrito.

Take a whole wheat tortilla. Put a generous strip of peanut butter from one edge, through the center point, and most of the way toward the other edge (like a diameter line, but only making it about 75 or 80% of the way across the tortilla).

Now put a thin line of fruit preserves alongside the peanut butter. There is refined sugar in this, even if you have “sweetened with fruit juice concentrate” preserves, so don’t use much. Or, use honey which is a healthier sweetener, even a “super food” according to some.

Now, lay a whole peeled banana on top of your PB&J strip

Fold over the not-covered part of the tortilla and wrap up like a burrito

There you have it.  In this “burrito,” you have healthy fats and protein from the peanut butter; healthy carbs and fiber from the tortilla; and healthy carbs, potassium, vitamin B6, vitamin C and anti-oxidants from the banana.  Note: a banana toward the greener/less-ripe end of the spectrum is a little better for you.

It was super-quick to make, easy to eat, and filling enough that you shouldn’t need any other lunch at that time. You’ll be ready for a mid-afternoon snack, which is a good idea within many guys’ daily routine, especially if you exercise after work.


Just as the journey of a thousand miles starts with a single step, the path to sustainable nutrition starts with finding specific, healthy things you like to eat and can easily prepare.  In that quest, I hope the humble peanut, and this humble post, are helpful.

“I’ve got some groceries, some peanut butter, to last a couple of days.” (Talking Heads, Life During Wartime — click to listen)

You may also like

Endurance , Fitness Planning & Gear , Mindfulness & Stress Management , Nutrition & Recipes , Strength

OlderBeast Weekly Web Picks: January 23, 2017

With all the great fitness, nutrition and wellness stuff out there on the Internet…there’s often too much to make sense of. Without an integrating philosophy and approach, it’s hard to interpret, prioritize and orchestrate everything into your own game plan. And your own plan is what you need, to sustain and thrive on for decades.

Helping you be your own Architect is OlderBeast’s core mission. Now, with OlderBeast philosophy as a foundation, we’re starting a weekly “best of the web” post at For fitness, nutrition and Wellness categories, it features a single, useful pointer to highly-relevant and useful stuff.

Fitness Planning & Gear , Nutrition & Recipes

Your Pig Day — Surprising Key to Long-term Nutrition Discipline

Eating well for life is partly about having a sound and practical plan, and (even more) about following that plan. We shouldn’t discount the importance of the “plan” part. So many “diets” or “programs” are harder to stick to than they need to be (or have a cost level few can sustain for the 10-20,000 days of living and eating we OlderBeasts have in front of us).

But this post is about the second challenge – following the plan. Let’s start with two premises:

1. We are all going to “cheat” vs. any plan sometimes (for me, that’s pizza and ice cream)

Nutrition & Recipes

Got Milk, or Not? Here’s How to Cut Through the Dairy Controversy.

OTHER THAN ORGANIC VEGETABLES, it seems like everything supposedly good for you also has “yeah, but” warnings about it.

Fish…mercury. Fruit…too much sugar. Nuts…high-calorie. Whole grains…carbs!

Dairy is controversial this way. Some very fit guys drink milk, eat dairy products, and use post-workout recovery drinks and energy bars with milk proteins. Others entirely shun dairy.

What should YOU do? Let’s look at pro’s and con’s, and my two cents on sorting this out to make your own decision.

Nutrition & Recipes

Three Squares? Why Higher Meal Frequency (5+) Is Better.

Seattle Seahawks QB Russell Wilson has reportedly lost 10+ pounds for the upcoming season — by eating NINE times a day.

News coverage also highlights a surprising daily calorie total (for anyone, let alone a guy losing weight): 4,800.

But Wilson is a young and large man (relative to non-NFL types) with a naturally-high metabolic rate. And, he’s extremely active with training camp starting in a few weeks.

So to me, the big story isn’t the calorie total. It’s the philosophy of eating more, smaller meals throughout the day. Nine is extreme, but eating 5-6 times a day isn’t so much. I recommend it for us 40+ guys trying to lose or manage weight, and fuel our bodies’ performance potential.

Here’s why.

  1. Shareef 1 year ago

    Great tip Mark. I’ve been dealing with this messy preamble for years. Another outstanding option: almond butter. It’s now my fave.

  2. Jennifer Young 1 year ago

    Awesome tip Mark! I will try this!! I’ve been struggling with this for years!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.